Calling a spade a spade

Bri
List: Absolutely awesome at posts. Always says when he'll hit and gives decent info on all appropriate targets before an hour to go.
War def cc troops: Does more than enough filling ccs
War attack cc troops: Doesn't loot on war days as is training war troops
War def: Needs to change base to be harder to 2 star
War attacks: Needs to learn to attack the top top bases again
Co-lead decision making: Decisive and makes most of the calls
Attack timing: Always mop up

Eprah
List: Good at posts, does tend to overemphasie those he prefers
War def cc troops: Awesome
War attack cc troops: Awesome
War def: Does change base up frequently to try and avoid giving 2
War attacks: Did loads of practice attacks to get better
Co-leads decision making: Could make more decisions
Attack timing: Good

BIC
List: Decent posts and on time. Should include when hitting
War def cc troops: No idea
War attack cc troops: No idea
War def: Often gives up 2
War attacks: Hit and miss, often gets the TH but needs to get the 50% to get 2 stars as well
Co-leads decision making: N/a
Attack timing: Attacks a bit to late to allow for mop up afterwards. Ideally should get first attack in first 12h

Patrick
List: Excellent
War def cc troops: Not sure
War attack cc troops: Decent I think
War def: Mixed, probably could look out a bit more base wise
War attacks: Pretty good at getting 2 off a lot of TH10s
Co-leads decision making: N/a tho if interested I'd consider it
Attack timing: Usually very good at getting attacks in a timely manner

Dingo
List: OK, could be a bit more thorough and doesn't say when he'll hit
War def cc troops: No idea
War attack cc troops: Does donate some
War def: Tough as a lower th10 to stop being 2 starred but needs to stay on top of it
War attacks: Usually does well on low TH10s and Mid level TH9s. Could look slightly higher
Co-leads decision making: N/a
Attack timing: Could do with getting first attack in earlier

Mistro
List: Brief but ok
War def cc troops: no idea
War attack cc troops: no idea, but donation records suggests v little
War def: Has been 3 starred but usually fine
War attacks: Usually delivers 3 on mid level th9s
Co-leads decision making: Very rarely gets involved
Attack timing: Usually fine

Ace
List: Very good detail, could cover all th9s to be excellent
War def cc troops: V Good
War attack cc troops: Good
War def: Decent
War attacks: Needs to figure out how to consistently get 3s off th9s
Co-leads decision making: Decent. Could make more
Attack timing: Fine

Samm
List: Decent
War def cc troops: V good
War attack cc troops: V good
War def: Does get 3 starred sometimes but usually changes up
War attacks: Hit lowish. Excellent get 1 star off th10s
Co-leads decision making: excellent
Attack timing: Always in a mop up role but does ok

AJ
List:
War def cc troops:
War attack cc troops:
War def:
War attacks:
Co-leads decision making:
Attack timing:

Matt
List: Very few if any
War def cc troops: no idea
War attack cc troops: no idea
War def: Holds up ok
War attacks: Attacks v low
Co-leads decision making: N/a
Attack timing: Needs to attack far earlier until he gets better at attacking TH9s

Bloody and Bloodyg
List: Good when on time
War def cc troops: V good
War attack cc troops: Pretty good
War def: Needs to keep changing up as struggled recently
War attacks: Usually excellent
Co-leads decision making: Could do more
Attack timing: Excellent

Sir Smoks
List: Good when on time
War def cc troops: V Good
War attack cc troops: pretty good
War def: Usually decent
War attacks: Usually excellent
Co-leads decision making: N/a
Attack timing: Excellent

Padre
List: List, what list? very narrow if done
War def cc troops: Could do more
War attack cc troops: Could do more
War def: Usually decent. Does change it up when needed
War attacks: Usually V good. Can be over ambitious at times
Co-leads decision making: Can be decisive when he wants
Attack timing: Unreliable at times

Derty
List: Slipping into bad habits. Needs to get back to decent posts on time everytime
War def cc troops: Don't think doing that much
War attack cc troops: Doing a bit when on
War def: Frequently gives up 3 and needs to keep on top of it
War attacks: Usually v good
Co-leads decision making: N/a
Attack timing: Needs to get first attack in earlier

Junglist
List: Excellent
War def cc troops: Used to be decent, unsure of lately
War attack cc troops: Used to be decent, unsure of lately
War def: Usually fine
War attacks: Decent. Is usually in the 2 high or 3 v low TH9 dilemma. Ideally gets more confident at TH9 3s.
Co-leads decision making: N/a
Attack timing: Always excellent

Cpt Obvious
List: Decent
War def cc troops: Ok
War attack cc troops: Pretty good
War def: Usually ok
War attacks: Getting better at 3s low TH9s. Needs to keep looking at other attack styles
Co-leads decision making: Could be more decisive and tell people where to hit
Attack timing: Excellent

bscoops
List: There's a list? Needs to extract the digit and get posting!
War def cc troops: Don't think he donates
War attack cc troops: Does a bit
War def: Does get hit for 3 sometimes, in that awkward phase where only dropping 2 could win wars
War attacks: Needs to move on from mopping up TH8s and leave that to lower TH9s. Instead should be focussing on either perfecting getting 2 off top TH9s or hitting low TH9s for 3
Co-leads decision making: N/a
Attack timing: Needs to get both attacks in earlier, ideally 1 in first 12h.

Stone
List:
War def cc troops:
War attack cc troops:
War def:
War attacks:
Co-leads decision making: N/a
Attack timing:


Mossy
List: Usually very good
War def cc troops: Unsure
War attack cc troops: Unsure
War def: Reasonable
War attacks: Very good.
Co-leads decision making: N/a
Attack timing: Needs to hit a bit earlier for first attack. Second attack can be a TH9 mop up

Espo
List: Usually Excellent
War def cc troops: Unsure
War attack cc troops: Does a bit
War def: In a crucial spot where a 2 instead of 3 could win a war
War attacks: Adapted to TH9 well and looks high for 2
Co-leads decision making: Do you think I'm nuts?!?
Attack timing: Usually excellent, could get second in earlier at times

Carp
List: Usually excellent
War def cc troops: Unsure
War attack cc troops: Unsure
War def: In a crucial spot where a 2 instead of 3 could win a war
War attacks: Does look at high TH9s for 2, reasonable success rate
Co-leads decision making: N/a
Attack timing: Usually excellent, could get second in earlier at times

Grumpy
List: Could expand the bases covered to look at all TH9s
War def cc troops: Excellent
War attack cc troops: Excellent when he can
War def: In a crucial spot where a 2 instead of 3 could win a war
War attacks: Using experience from sknab well, getting some good 3s on low TH9s
Co-leads decision making: Doesn't get involved but could be good. Working in SH2 will help
Attack timing: Excellent

B Blazin
List: Needs to cover all TH9s, more to get in the habit.
War def cc troops: Limited troops can still do some
War attack cc troops: Limited troops can still do some
War def: Tough job but every 2 star is a victory
War attacks: Doing ok, needs to watch carp, espo, mossy and grumpy closely
Co-leads decision making: N/a
Attack timing: Should make sure he hits once early and ep second by 5h to go at absolute latest

Slic
List:
War def cc troops:
War attack cc troops:
War def:
War attacks:
Co-leads decision making:
Attack timing:

Mauriceminor
List:
War def cc troops:
War attack cc troops:
War def:
War attacks:
Co-leads decision making:
Attack timing:

King Green
List:
War def cc troops:
War attack cc troops:
War def:
War attacks:
Co-leads decision making:
Attack timing:

Potatomuncher
List:
War def cc troops:
War attack cc troops:
War def:
War attacks:
Co-leads decision making:
Attack timing:

Il padroso
List:
War def cc troops:
War attack cc troops:
War def:
War attacks:
Co-leads decision making:
Attack timing:

Diesel
List:
War def cc troops:
War attack cc troops:
War def:
War attacks:
Co-leads decision making:
Attack timing:

Mikes
List:
War def cc troops:
War attack cc troops:
War def:
War attacks:
Co-leads decision making:
Attack timing:

Mastermind
List:
War def cc troops:
War attack cc troops:
War def:
War attacks:
Co-leads decision making:
Attack timing:

Bess
List:
War def cc troops:
War attack cc troops:
War def:
War attacks:
Co-leads decision making:
Attack timing:

Twon
List:
War def cc troops:
War attack cc troops:
War def:
War attacks:
Co-leads decision making:
Attack timing:

Slim shady
List:
War def cc troops:
War attack cc troops:
War def:
War attacks:
Co-leads decision making:
Attack timing:

Titus
List:
War def cc troops:
War attack cc troops:
War def:
War attacks:
Co-leads decision making:
Attack timing:

Leidi
List:
War def cc troops:
War attack cc troops:
War def:
War attacks:
Co-leads decision making:
Attack timing:

Ric
List:
War def cc troops:
War attack cc troops:
War def:
War attacks:
Co-leads decision making:
Attack timing: