Post by Bri on May 31, 2015 22:39:21 GMT
This is supposed to be constructive criticism, not an attack or ego building exercise on anyone.
Bri
Likes bubble baths, sunsets and long walks on the beach.Recieved a bachelor's degree in philosophy (no idea what he was thinking). Once bowled a perfect 300.
Eprah
War contribution: Great at donating troops both defence and attacking CCs in war.
Attacks: A bit one trick, but it works and frequently get 2 stars off TH10s.
Defence: Base does get 2 starred. That is hard to stop with good opponents. Can only suggest experimenting until 1 starts holding to 1 star more often.
Posts: Sometimes over optimistic in what you can achieve and that results in wasted attacks.
BIC
War contribution: Haven’t seen whether there has been much war troop donation
Attacks: Need to find at least one style that can get you either 2 stars of TH10s or 3 stars of mid-level TH9s. Hounds, Dragons or Golems maxed are the options that will let you do that. Sit out wars, watch our replays of what is going well or not and practice yourself. Bear in mind practice isn’t quite the same as war but pick really hard bases and it gets close.
Defence: Base seems to hold up ok in war, some 2 stars some 1 star. Better walls will help slow down attackers.
Posts: Yours post last war was fine, just over optimistic.
Make sure you include a rough time of attack. When you start warring again I’ll want you hitting both attacks before last 6 hours so we know if we need to clean up or not.
Patrick
War contribution: Great at donating troops for attacking CC’s and I know you have done defence CC’s before but war start timing isn’t great for you.
Attacks: On a learning curve but pretty good. More comfortable with ground and I think 2 starring TH10s rather than trying to get 3 off TH9s. You have all the troops and spells you need and good heroes. Sometimes I think you don’t consider if inferno is on multi and then lose witches to that, but you are good at holding back a few mop up troops. As a general rule if hitting a TH9 I wouldn’t take freeze spell
Defence: You normally hold up ok though this war was a scare for 3 stars. You know to change xbows and infernos. I’d use gold to work on traps a bit to get them up and use elixir on walls.
Posts: Your posts are fine. Don’t mind you listing down to about 14 in war if you think you have a chance of 3 on bases that low.
Bubba
War contribution: Tend to do little in SH as I do a lot for SH2
Attacks: Usually late and where I think it’s needed. Occasionally overly ambitious and fail. Need to think outside of Golaloon sometimes
Defence: Need to add another base as have been 3 starred a few times recently
Posts: Usually detailed
Mistro
War Contribution: Think you have been busy lately so haven’t been on as much. Could do with more contributions to defence CC’s.
Attacks: Usually pretty good. Probably need to learn more attack styles to get 3 stars rather than just 2 stars off TH9s
Defence: Usually pretty good. Probably need to have a couple of bases in case you start giving up 3s.
Posts: You haven’t really needed to before but know that you do in future.
Samm
War Contribution: Pretty good. Good at leading and allocating bases if I’m not about or want a break
Attacks: Great at 1 star off TH10s. Need to get more confidence at taking 3 off TH9s
Defence: Usually ok, you keep an eye on your base and change it if you think you need to. Maxed apart from little bombs?
Posts: Usually brief as you know you are likely in mop up but it’s good for you to add in a TH9 or 2 you can 3 star.
Derty
War contribution: Usually good
Attacks: Good at getting 3 stars and should keep trying for that. Probably would be better if you hit earlier in war though so if you do fail we know where to mop up with solid 2 stars.
Defences: Hit and miss though you are on top of it and change your base when you need to
Posts: Sometimes over optimistic. Would prefer a base by base breakdown of confidence.
Darra
War contribution: Very little recently though have been helping out SH2.
Attacks: Arguably our best and most consistent at getting TH9 3 stars. One trick, but it works so don’t change. Sometimes think you waste attacks by not looking at bigger picture and you hit a mid-range for 2 rather than a high target for 2 and freeing up someone higher or a low target for 3.
Defences: I know you are looking more at your defences and base now.
Posts: Well you have started doing some which is nice! I’d prefer a few more targets listed just so we look at bigger picture. Also earlier posts if possible, just so your preferred target isn’t given to someone else and then is a wasted attack.
General: Could do with getting your heroes up. At least 15-15 before think about TH10
Jung
War contribution: Could do with more defence CC donations. You have some great ideas.
Attacks: Great at hitting low for 3 stars and willing to take on top TH9s for 2 stars. Only area to improve is finding an attack style that lets you get 3 stars a bit higher
Defence: Pretty good. Don’t remember 3 stars off you recently and you do monitor your base
Posts: Excellent and usually pretty accurate.
Eacho
War Contribution: You haven’t been in many wars with us but I know you have helped out SH2 a lot and been good with advice for others.
Attacks: You clearly know what you are doing
Defence: Honestly can’t remember
Posts: Similar to Darra. I want you to get the targets you can get 3 off so we don’t waste attacks on them.
Bloody
War Contribution: You have done loads for defence CC’s
Attacks: Good at getting 3 on lower TH9s and trying mid TH9s. Stronger heroes will help you.
Defence: Usually ok
Posts: Excellent
Quick
War Contribution: You do a lot for SH2 so not worried about SH
Attacks: Doing really well learning Gowiho and Golaloon. There will be the odd failure but they are higher risk attacks and if you are hitting early then they can be mopped up.
Defence: I think its ok. Last war was a TH10 getting 3 after 2 failures before. Keep an eye on it though.
Posts: Excellent
Capt Obv
War contribution: Pretty good at helping fill war defence CC’s.
Attacks: Need to find an attack style that is more consistent at getting 3 stars off lower TH9s. You are getting the odd 3 but failing a lot more. Ideally you should be getting 3s off TH9s more often, then looking at higher targets eventually. Heroes are decent, consider getting golems up so Golaloon or GoWiHo are options.
Defence: You base holds up well
Posts: Split out the 2-3 star and confidence level so it is 2 star 8 confidence and 3 star 6 confidence. With your attacks it isn’t always a case of if you don’t get 3 you get 2 because they are higher risk. Otherwise posts are excellent
Smoksalot
War Contribution: Excellent. Done loads of witches for Defence CC’s and also helped SH2
Attacks: Pretty good. Good at low TH9 3 stars. Maybe need to think about looking at top TH9s for 2 stars as well as mid-level.
Defence: Don’t even think about changing your base!
Posts: Similar to Dan, break out the 3 star and 2 star confidence. Because yours are ground attack it is very likely you get 2 if you don’t get the 3. Don’t forget to add time of attacks into posts. Generally excellent posts.
Ace
War Contribution: Decent. Your work times mean you are on at different hours than most. Good advice for TH8s with drag attacks
Attacks: Getting to the stage where you need to explore other attack styles as you aren’t doing quite as well with drags as we face harder bases these days.
Defence: You keep an eye on it and change it if you get 3 starred frequently
Posts: Excellent
King Green
War Contribution: Could be better I think. Don’t know how often you are on when defence CC’s are being filled
War Attacks: You have been doing a mop up role for a while and doing it well. Getting to the stage where ideally you shouldn’t be hitting TH8’s (others need to step up there) but instead you should be looking to add stars off TH9s. Golaloon could be a good variation for you to work on in addition to current attacks.
Defence: Usually fine.
Posts: It would be nice to see one even just for novelty value! In all seriousness it would help planning the last few hours if we knew you were more confident of one base over another.
Godzilla
War contribution: Could be better I think. Don’t know how often you are on when defence CC’s are being filled
Attacks: Hit and miss. Doing ok at getting low TH9s 3 starred. Ideally want to refine your attack style or develop new ones so you can attack a bit higher up as well.
Defence: Usually good
Posts: Fine. Info is all there just need a tweak on layout so can see everything at a glance rather then reading sentences.
Slic
War Contribution: Could do with helping more with Defence CC’s. Used to be exceptional.
Attacks: Struggling to get 3 stars these days and mostly posting for lowish level TH9s for 2 stars. Try and cover higher bases for 2 stars as well as that will help. Spells could do with being maxed out which will help your attacks. Golems almost maxed for TH9 and heroes are decent.
Defence: You base is borderline. Some wars it holds up loads of attacks, others it is 3 starred pretty quickly. Have another 1 or even 2 ready to try at some stage. Look at bases we struggle to 3 star around your level and copy them.
Posts: Fine though add in rough time you expect to attack.
Destructo Donny
We seek him here we seek him there that damned elusive Destructo Donny.
Thought I’d include you for completeness. I expect you will be a little rusty war attack wise. I’d max out your heal spell but otherwise your troops look like you have plenty of attack options. Base looks like defences at good level, loving the walls.
Sknab
War contribution: Doing loads for SH2 and helping out in SH
Attacks: Generally aiming for 2 and getting the occasional 3. Need to figure out what the next step is. Learn another attack style?
Defence: Generally good.
Posts: Excellent. I’d maybe look at more bases in case there are lower you think you can get 3 from or higher you could also 2 star.
Mossy
War contribution: Could be better I think. Don’t know how often you are on when defence CC’s are being filled
Attacks: Learning well. Could do with hitting early in wars and trying for 3 stars then we can mop up if you fail. Troops and heroes need a bit of work, golems will help with GoWiHo. If you leave your attacks late you will be on TH8 mop up duty.
Defence: As a low TH9 you will likely be vulnerable. Just try and make them really work for 3 stars. If you are giving up 3 earlyish think about changing to a base with CC and AQ central and off centre TH that might be an easier 2 but harder 3.
Posts: Very good, but look for the 3 stars.
Scoops
War contribution: Haven’t been about long enough to assess
Attacks: Very good at mopping up TH8s. Hopefully we can test you higher up soon and see how you go against TH9s. If you want to try that we will want 1 attack early in war and can leave your second for mop up.
Defence: Fine, though I’d get a couple of Air Defences up.
Posts: Try and look at the lower TH9s and list out base by base what you think. Happy to leave TH8s as a block. Also let us know each war if both attacks in that 6h-1h to go window is best or if you want to try a TH9 earlier.
Espo
War contribution: General clown? As your troops get up you will be asked to help a bit.
Attacks: For now you might be best in a TH8 mop up role if you can wait until last 8h. If you see TH9s you can 3 star then certainly put them in your post and same as Scoops I’m happy for you to have a crack at them early.
Defence: As a low TH9 you will likely be vulnerable. Just try and make them really work for 3 stars. If you are giving up 3 earlyish think about changing to a base with CC and AQ central and off centre TH that might be an easier 2 but harder 3.
Posts: Keep doing them just to stay in the habit of it
Carp
Attacks: Doing well with your ground attacks.
Defence: As a TH8 all you can do is stop them getting you first time and ideally force a TH9 to get the 3.
Posts: Very good
Gamey
Attacks: I know it’s hard for you do it, but hitting earlyish does make it easier for others clean up the TH8s. If you can’t do that then at least if we have a post we can figure out what targets you take. Some of your hog attacks have been great.
Defence: As a TH8 all you can do is stop them getting you first time and ideally force a TH9 to get the 3.
Posts: I know they are a pain but even a few lines helps us to plan the mop up.
PJM
Attacks: I know you feel like you have hit a brick wall with drags. You have lvl4 hogs if you want to try something different
Defence: As a TH8 all you can do is stop them getting you first time and ideally force a TH9 to get the 3.
Posts: Very good
B Blazin
Attacks: Pretty good
Defence: As a TH8 all you can do is stop them getting you first time and ideally force a TH9 to get the 3.
Posts: Good, but layout wise a list is easier to read
Win
Attacks: Good
Defence: As a TH8 all you can do is stop them getting you first time and ideally force a TH9 to get the 3.
Posts: Very good
Mikes
Attacks: Very Good
Defence: As a TH8 all you can do is stop them getting you first time and ideally force a TH9 to get the 3.
Posts: Very good
Bri
Likes bubble baths, sunsets and long walks on the beach.Recieved a bachelor's degree in philosophy (no idea what he was thinking). Once bowled a perfect 300.
Eprah
War contribution: Great at donating troops both defence and attacking CCs in war.
Attacks: A bit one trick, but it works and frequently get 2 stars off TH10s.
Defence: Base does get 2 starred. That is hard to stop with good opponents. Can only suggest experimenting until 1 starts holding to 1 star more often.
Posts: Sometimes over optimistic in what you can achieve and that results in wasted attacks.
BIC
War contribution: Haven’t seen whether there has been much war troop donation
Attacks: Need to find at least one style that can get you either 2 stars of TH10s or 3 stars of mid-level TH9s. Hounds, Dragons or Golems maxed are the options that will let you do that. Sit out wars, watch our replays of what is going well or not and practice yourself. Bear in mind practice isn’t quite the same as war but pick really hard bases and it gets close.
Defence: Base seems to hold up ok in war, some 2 stars some 1 star. Better walls will help slow down attackers.
Posts: Yours post last war was fine, just over optimistic.
Make sure you include a rough time of attack. When you start warring again I’ll want you hitting both attacks before last 6 hours so we know if we need to clean up or not.
Patrick
War contribution: Great at donating troops for attacking CC’s and I know you have done defence CC’s before but war start timing isn’t great for you.
Attacks: On a learning curve but pretty good. More comfortable with ground and I think 2 starring TH10s rather than trying to get 3 off TH9s. You have all the troops and spells you need and good heroes. Sometimes I think you don’t consider if inferno is on multi and then lose witches to that, but you are good at holding back a few mop up troops. As a general rule if hitting a TH9 I wouldn’t take freeze spell
Defence: You normally hold up ok though this war was a scare for 3 stars. You know to change xbows and infernos. I’d use gold to work on traps a bit to get them up and use elixir on walls.
Posts: Your posts are fine. Don’t mind you listing down to about 14 in war if you think you have a chance of 3 on bases that low.
Bubba
War contribution: Tend to do little in SH as I do a lot for SH2
Attacks: Usually late and where I think it’s needed. Occasionally overly ambitious and fail. Need to think outside of Golaloon sometimes
Defence: Need to add another base as have been 3 starred a few times recently
Posts: Usually detailed
Mistro
War Contribution: Think you have been busy lately so haven’t been on as much. Could do with more contributions to defence CC’s.
Attacks: Usually pretty good. Probably need to learn more attack styles to get 3 stars rather than just 2 stars off TH9s
Defence: Usually pretty good. Probably need to have a couple of bases in case you start giving up 3s.
Posts: You haven’t really needed to before but know that you do in future.
Samm
War Contribution: Pretty good. Good at leading and allocating bases if I’m not about or want a break
Attacks: Great at 1 star off TH10s. Need to get more confidence at taking 3 off TH9s
Defence: Usually ok, you keep an eye on your base and change it if you think you need to. Maxed apart from little bombs?
Posts: Usually brief as you know you are likely in mop up but it’s good for you to add in a TH9 or 2 you can 3 star.
Derty
War contribution: Usually good
Attacks: Good at getting 3 stars and should keep trying for that. Probably would be better if you hit earlier in war though so if you do fail we know where to mop up with solid 2 stars.
Defences: Hit and miss though you are on top of it and change your base when you need to
Posts: Sometimes over optimistic. Would prefer a base by base breakdown of confidence.
Darra
War contribution: Very little recently though have been helping out SH2.
Attacks: Arguably our best and most consistent at getting TH9 3 stars. One trick, but it works so don’t change. Sometimes think you waste attacks by not looking at bigger picture and you hit a mid-range for 2 rather than a high target for 2 and freeing up someone higher or a low target for 3.
Defences: I know you are looking more at your defences and base now.
Posts: Well you have started doing some which is nice! I’d prefer a few more targets listed just so we look at bigger picture. Also earlier posts if possible, just so your preferred target isn’t given to someone else and then is a wasted attack.
General: Could do with getting your heroes up. At least 15-15 before think about TH10
Jung
War contribution: Could do with more defence CC donations. You have some great ideas.
Attacks: Great at hitting low for 3 stars and willing to take on top TH9s for 2 stars. Only area to improve is finding an attack style that lets you get 3 stars a bit higher
Defence: Pretty good. Don’t remember 3 stars off you recently and you do monitor your base
Posts: Excellent and usually pretty accurate.
Eacho
War Contribution: You haven’t been in many wars with us but I know you have helped out SH2 a lot and been good with advice for others.
Attacks: You clearly know what you are doing
Defence: Honestly can’t remember
Posts: Similar to Darra. I want you to get the targets you can get 3 off so we don’t waste attacks on them.
Bloody
War Contribution: You have done loads for defence CC’s
Attacks: Good at getting 3 on lower TH9s and trying mid TH9s. Stronger heroes will help you.
Defence: Usually ok
Posts: Excellent
Quick
War Contribution: You do a lot for SH2 so not worried about SH
Attacks: Doing really well learning Gowiho and Golaloon. There will be the odd failure but they are higher risk attacks and if you are hitting early then they can be mopped up.
Defence: I think its ok. Last war was a TH10 getting 3 after 2 failures before. Keep an eye on it though.
Posts: Excellent
Capt Obv
War contribution: Pretty good at helping fill war defence CC’s.
Attacks: Need to find an attack style that is more consistent at getting 3 stars off lower TH9s. You are getting the odd 3 but failing a lot more. Ideally you should be getting 3s off TH9s more often, then looking at higher targets eventually. Heroes are decent, consider getting golems up so Golaloon or GoWiHo are options.
Defence: You base holds up well
Posts: Split out the 2-3 star and confidence level so it is 2 star 8 confidence and 3 star 6 confidence. With your attacks it isn’t always a case of if you don’t get 3 you get 2 because they are higher risk. Otherwise posts are excellent
Smoksalot
War Contribution: Excellent. Done loads of witches for Defence CC’s and also helped SH2
Attacks: Pretty good. Good at low TH9 3 stars. Maybe need to think about looking at top TH9s for 2 stars as well as mid-level.
Defence: Don’t even think about changing your base!
Posts: Similar to Dan, break out the 3 star and 2 star confidence. Because yours are ground attack it is very likely you get 2 if you don’t get the 3. Don’t forget to add time of attacks into posts. Generally excellent posts.
Ace
War Contribution: Decent. Your work times mean you are on at different hours than most. Good advice for TH8s with drag attacks
Attacks: Getting to the stage where you need to explore other attack styles as you aren’t doing quite as well with drags as we face harder bases these days.
Defence: You keep an eye on it and change it if you get 3 starred frequently
Posts: Excellent
King Green
War Contribution: Could be better I think. Don’t know how often you are on when defence CC’s are being filled
War Attacks: You have been doing a mop up role for a while and doing it well. Getting to the stage where ideally you shouldn’t be hitting TH8’s (others need to step up there) but instead you should be looking to add stars off TH9s. Golaloon could be a good variation for you to work on in addition to current attacks.
Defence: Usually fine.
Posts: It would be nice to see one even just for novelty value! In all seriousness it would help planning the last few hours if we knew you were more confident of one base over another.
Godzilla
War contribution: Could be better I think. Don’t know how often you are on when defence CC’s are being filled
Attacks: Hit and miss. Doing ok at getting low TH9s 3 starred. Ideally want to refine your attack style or develop new ones so you can attack a bit higher up as well.
Defence: Usually good
Posts: Fine. Info is all there just need a tweak on layout so can see everything at a glance rather then reading sentences.
Slic
War Contribution: Could do with helping more with Defence CC’s. Used to be exceptional.
Attacks: Struggling to get 3 stars these days and mostly posting for lowish level TH9s for 2 stars. Try and cover higher bases for 2 stars as well as that will help. Spells could do with being maxed out which will help your attacks. Golems almost maxed for TH9 and heroes are decent.
Defence: You base is borderline. Some wars it holds up loads of attacks, others it is 3 starred pretty quickly. Have another 1 or even 2 ready to try at some stage. Look at bases we struggle to 3 star around your level and copy them.
Posts: Fine though add in rough time you expect to attack.
Destructo Donny
We seek him here we seek him there that damned elusive Destructo Donny.
Thought I’d include you for completeness. I expect you will be a little rusty war attack wise. I’d max out your heal spell but otherwise your troops look like you have plenty of attack options. Base looks like defences at good level, loving the walls.
Sknab
War contribution: Doing loads for SH2 and helping out in SH
Attacks: Generally aiming for 2 and getting the occasional 3. Need to figure out what the next step is. Learn another attack style?
Defence: Generally good.
Posts: Excellent. I’d maybe look at more bases in case there are lower you think you can get 3 from or higher you could also 2 star.
Mossy
War contribution: Could be better I think. Don’t know how often you are on when defence CC’s are being filled
Attacks: Learning well. Could do with hitting early in wars and trying for 3 stars then we can mop up if you fail. Troops and heroes need a bit of work, golems will help with GoWiHo. If you leave your attacks late you will be on TH8 mop up duty.
Defence: As a low TH9 you will likely be vulnerable. Just try and make them really work for 3 stars. If you are giving up 3 earlyish think about changing to a base with CC and AQ central and off centre TH that might be an easier 2 but harder 3.
Posts: Very good, but look for the 3 stars.
Scoops
War contribution: Haven’t been about long enough to assess
Attacks: Very good at mopping up TH8s. Hopefully we can test you higher up soon and see how you go against TH9s. If you want to try that we will want 1 attack early in war and can leave your second for mop up.
Defence: Fine, though I’d get a couple of Air Defences up.
Posts: Try and look at the lower TH9s and list out base by base what you think. Happy to leave TH8s as a block. Also let us know each war if both attacks in that 6h-1h to go window is best or if you want to try a TH9 earlier.
Espo
War contribution: General clown? As your troops get up you will be asked to help a bit.
Attacks: For now you might be best in a TH8 mop up role if you can wait until last 8h. If you see TH9s you can 3 star then certainly put them in your post and same as Scoops I’m happy for you to have a crack at them early.
Defence: As a low TH9 you will likely be vulnerable. Just try and make them really work for 3 stars. If you are giving up 3 earlyish think about changing to a base with CC and AQ central and off centre TH that might be an easier 2 but harder 3.
Posts: Keep doing them just to stay in the habit of it
Carp
Attacks: Doing well with your ground attacks.
Defence: As a TH8 all you can do is stop them getting you first time and ideally force a TH9 to get the 3.
Posts: Very good
Gamey
Attacks: I know it’s hard for you do it, but hitting earlyish does make it easier for others clean up the TH8s. If you can’t do that then at least if we have a post we can figure out what targets you take. Some of your hog attacks have been great.
Defence: As a TH8 all you can do is stop them getting you first time and ideally force a TH9 to get the 3.
Posts: I know they are a pain but even a few lines helps us to plan the mop up.
PJM
Attacks: I know you feel like you have hit a brick wall with drags. You have lvl4 hogs if you want to try something different
Defence: As a TH8 all you can do is stop them getting you first time and ideally force a TH9 to get the 3.
Posts: Very good
B Blazin
Attacks: Pretty good
Defence: As a TH8 all you can do is stop them getting you first time and ideally force a TH9 to get the 3.
Posts: Good, but layout wise a list is easier to read
Win
Attacks: Good
Defence: As a TH8 all you can do is stop them getting you first time and ideally force a TH9 to get the 3.
Posts: Very good
Mikes
Attacks: Very Good
Defence: As a TH8 all you can do is stop them getting you first time and ideally force a TH9 to get the 3.
Posts: Very good
